Montauk Yacht Club Inn

These guys will charge you $100 for "access to all of our amenities, fitness center, pools, shore cruises ect" on top of what you already paid ---- Edit: be aware when you book this place on agoda. Agoda will charge you $100 "surcharge fee", but when you check in, hotel will charge you another $100 for the same reason. Overall the place is good. People are friendly. Food is not bad. Location is good.

I had such a great experience thanks to Mr. Peeters! He helped us get into the room we needed so effortlessly and gave us an amazing welcome. He made sure I had everything I needed for my stay and went above and beyond with his professionalism. Very impressive young man, I’ll definitely be returning!

We got married here and came back for our 10 year anniversary. The hotel has changed hands a couple of times in that time but they’ve got it right this time. The rooms are very nicely decorated, beds comfy, and the service is top notch. Highly recommend.

Dinner last week with friends. Food very average and over priced. Service, Maria V. was not good. Attitude issue and little things like no plates and utensils for sharing when we advised of same upfront regarding a few salads. Oysters were okay if you liked the cheese totally overwhelming the oyster-or was it a clam-a mussel-a conch? Lobster pasta was okay. Steak was average. The location remains beautiful but this new group is not welcoming nor cordial.

My husband and I really wanted a nice weekend away with our 5 month old baby. We thought going to a place charging $1100 a night would be a bit more upscale and better. How wrong we were. First when we entered the room, there was a massive wasp flying around inside. Next we specifically asked for a crib and when they forgot to put it in room. When they brought it, the sheets were visibly dirty. Later that night when we came back we wanted to relax in our room, but they had the loudest DJ outside you would have thought you were sleeping next to the DJ booth. We went to reception the next morning to change rooms, and while they did accommodate us, they rushed us to get out of the room we were currently in. We decided we wanted to go to the pool but were told we were not allowed to use the main pool which is now “adults only” and were told we could use the pool down the road. This pool had no pool side service (like the adult pool does). Later that night in our room you could still hear the DJ even though not as loud. The room next to us decided to throw a party in their room and I called the front desk to break it up and they did send someone, but whoever they sent literally said to the guest “an annoying guest needs you to stop the party. Let me comp you drinks at the bar”. An annoying guest? I had a 5 month old infant in the room and paid $2200 for 2 days!!! They didn’t even offer a free breakfast, drink or anything to us. My advice - don’t waste your money. It’s a glorified motel and they are not great at hospitality.