The Muttontown Club: Muttontown

After getting engaged, my fiance and I were looking for a venue for our wedding for a while, and nothing seemed to inspire us. My parents recommended the Muttontown Club, so we decided to meet with Robert to see if they could hold our fairly large group. From the start, Robert seemed like he actually cared about us as a couple! He is full of energy and will customize your wedding to fit you. The Club is truly beautiful and we felt so taken care of. The food is AMAZING and the team is so professional. Often, wedding venues can feel like wedding factories. This is not that. The Muttontown Club is a special place that made us feel like family. They really valued our thoughts and opinions, and were willing to do whatever it took to give us the most amazing day. Everything ran so smoothly and perfectly. It was the most fun we have ever had. Our friends and family can’t stop talking about the night. We feel incredibly blessed!!! We cannot thank the staff enough!!!

My wife and I were married at The Muttontown Club and we could not have imagined a more perfect venue. From start to finish, our experience was nothing short of exceptional. Robert and his entire team went above and beyond to cater to our every need. Their professionalism, attention to detail, and genuine care made the entire planning process seamless and stress-free. No request or ask was too big and while the Club hosts many weddings, we always felt like our wedding was their top priority. The food and venue are also top notch with numerous food options that are all curated for each couple. This was especially important to us as we had a number of wedding guests with severe food allergies. The team at The Muttontown Club took great care to ensure all allergies were accounted for and delicious substitutes were available (including an entirely gluten free desert table!!!). We would highly recommend any couple getting married on Long Island to consider The Muttontown Club!

Our experience with the team at the Muttontown Club was nothing short of exceptional!!! From the very first communication to the final moments of our wedding night, the Muttontown Club team went above and beyond to make our day absolutely perfect. The venue itself is elegant, timeless, and so beautifully maintained, but it was the team that truly made our wedding unforgettable. They anticipated our needs before we even voiced them, handled every detail with professionalism and care, and made the entire planning process feel seamless. We never had to worry about a thing because they had already thought of it. One of the most important elements to us as we were planning was the food. Guests might forget the small details, but they always remember the food. Let's just say our guests are still raving to us about the amazing food on our wedding day. If you’re looking for a venue where the team treats your wedding like their top priority, go to the Muttontown Club! They helped create the wedding day of our dreams, and we are forever grateful. Sending the most heartfelt thank you to Rob, Nicole, Jen, DJ, and Laiba.

I recently hosted 2 birthday parties at The Muttontown Club (one this past August and one this month) and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. Rob and the entire staff were absolutely amazing, accommodating all of my requests and questions with patience and professionalism. Despite my million emails to Rob and Samantha, they ensured every detail was perfect, making the both events were truly special. The service is top-notch, and the venue was beautiful. I highly recommend The Muttontown Club for any event—you’ll be in great hands! (I brought the decor myself but the staff set it all up!)

We had an incredible experience hosting our daughter's baptism here in the Oak Room at The Muttontown Club which hosts about 80 people! We initially chose the location since it was near our church. From start to finish the entire experience was great. Even just driving into the club the grounds are magnificent and give a great first impression. Tara was very thorough and helpful with keeping things organized down to the last detail. The space itself is beautiful, has a gorgeous charm to it and opens up to the outside which was amazing for our guests on a beautiful summer day to see members golfing it was just breathtaking. My favorite part of that room is that it also opens to a beautiful sunroom where we did a nice display, so when you entered the Oak Room you could see straight down into the sun room. Big standouts for us were the food (honestly amazing, we did a lunch and my family is in the restaurant business and are tough critics but kept raving about how amazing the food was) and the staff (kind, attentive, didn't miss a beat). They also had high chairs which was great and made the location family friendly. The price was also fair and they made the day very special for us, a great experience overall highly recommend!