Gardiners Bay Country Club, Shelter Island, New York
31 Manhanset Road
About the home
31 Manhanset Road sits in Dering Harbor on Shelter Island, New York. Directly across Manhanset Road lie the fairways of Gardiners Bay Country Club, which offers golf. The 8.1-acre parcel was once part of Oriole Farm, the private arboretum and cultivated gardens of horticulturist Alice Fisk.
Features
Private Pool
Spa
Property details
Prices in USD
- List price
- $2,895,000
Cost of ownership
$15,097/month
over 30 yrs, with property tax
Loan amount
$2,316,000
Principal & interest
$14,639
- These figures are estimates you set, not a loan offer or a quoted rate
- Speak to a lender for current rates
- Estimates do not include insurance or club membership fees
- HOA dues start at the listing's figure when it states one
Listed by
Gary DePersia - Associate Real Estate Broker
Corcoran Group
Shelter Island, New York
Gardiners Bay Country Club
Membership
Private Clubs team
31 Manhanset Road, Shelter Island, New York 11964
Nearest Airports
- ISP
Long Island MacArthur Airport Commercial
45 mi - GON
Groton New London Airport Private Jets
22 mi - FOK
Francis S Gabreski Airport Private Jets
23 mi
Prices in USD
| Event | Date | Price | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listed for sale | Jul 2026 | $2,895,0000% | 0% |
| Listing removed | May 2026 | $2,895,0000% | 0% |
| Listed for sale | Mar 2026 | $2,895,0000% | 0% |
| Listing removed | Aug 2025 | $2,895,0000% | 0% |
| Listed for sale | Feb 2025 | $2,895,000-19.5% | -19.5% |
| Listing removed | Jan 2025 | $3,595,0000% | 0% |
| Listed for sale | Aug 2024 | $3,595,000-58% | -58% |
| Listing removed | Dec 2021 | ||
| Listed for sale | Jun 2021 | $8,550,000-0.3% | -0.3% |
| Listing removed | Jun 2020 | $8,575,0000% | 0% |
| Listed for sale | Apr 2018 | $8,575,0000% | 0% |
| Listing removed | Dec 2017 | $8,575,0000% | 0% |
Source: Zillow
